That was, until today.
In no surprise to anyone, the extra AF packaging is winning hearts all over Instagram before either brand has even made mention of the product on their official accounts.
Blogger for the brand, Amelia here, posted the sneak peek.
Fact: Us unicorn-chasing, glitter-butt obsessed millennials can sniff out even the tiniest new speck of sparkle on the 'gram.
We'll just be sitting here, refreshing the Glossier Instagram page until we find out exactly how we can get our hands on this glorious, cake-scented lip sparkle.