One of the ~obvious~ signs? Phoebe and Paul aren’t following each other on Instagram anymore — a telling clue with any relationship, really.
It was first reported back in March that Phoebe and Paul, who met on the set of The Vampire Diaries, had broken up after four years together.
We thought love was dead. But then there was a ray of light the following month, when reports said they were back together! Aside from being spotted on a “romantic dinner date” in L.A., Phoebe posted a photo of Paul on Instagram — once again, always a sign!
Phoebe and Paul, who often attended events together and were just super cute all ’round, started dating around the time Paul’s divorce from his wife Torrey DeVito was finalised.
While they weren’t the most public couple, Phoebe had sweet things to say about Paul in a 2015 interview with ELLE Canada. “He’s my best friend. It’s such a fun time in my life right now,” she said. “It’s nice to have someone to share all that with.”
R.I.P. love (again).